login / register
On Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, Trump jerks off to a picture of Ivanka.
Welcome to Ubersite!

Donovan's 2005 Oscar Picks

Submitted by ryandonovan at 2005-02-15 22:11:51 EST
Rating: 1.81 on 61 ratings (61 reviews) (Review this item) (V)

DONOVAN’S OSCAR PROGNOSTICATION 2005

It was an interesting year for movies, in that there were an abundance of good and great films, but very few superb ones (plenty of 4’s, but not many 5’s). When asked my opinion of movies I saw, my answer always seemed to be “It was really good, but…” You hate to have to put a qualifier on the Best Pictures of the year.

I’d like to declare a mistrial on this year’s Academy Awards, since the year’s true Best Picture, Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind, was not even considered as a nominee. But, in the name of liberty, we shall persevere, and hold the ceremony anyway.

In a year with so many tight races, you’ll need my Sixth Annual Oscar Predictions to prep for the big night. Why am I qualified? I hate to brag, but let me remind you that I was a perfect 8-for-8 last year (I am also a 6-6-6, in case any of you ladies are wondering).

Did you know that Alanis Morissette is engaged to Ryan “Van Wilder” Reynolds? That doesn't have anything to do with the Oscars, I just thought it was really freaking bizarre.

BEST PICTURE:
SHOULD WIN: Sideways
WILL WIN: Sideways
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Alexander
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

While none of the nominees felt to me like a TRULY GREAT FILM, I’m leaning Sideways. Even though I’m not a middle-aged divorced alcoholic and failed novelist, there were things about the film that I strongly identified with. And it is certainly lighter than Million Dollar Baby (the scene where Paul Giamatti retrieves the wallet made me laugh harder than I have in a long time). However, the fact that the Academy gave Clint Eastwood an acting nomination in lieu of Giamatti suggests that they might disagree with me for Best Picture.

In my spotless mind, this year’s Best Picture should rightfully be Eternal Sunshine. It was superb in so many ways, but the clincher for me was the ending (I won’t give anything away here). As the film draws to a close, you know the credits are coming, but you have no idea how it will get wrapped up. You know it’s the last scene, and it’s still a mess. A million untied ends, a million questions. Then, one word of dialogue - one common, throw-away word - and everything is answered. Genius. The best one-word summation since “Rosebud”.

While The Aviator has some momentum, coming off a Golden Globe victory, I don’t think it will win the Oscar. Biopics are tough nuts to crack, and as nuts go, there are none bigger than Howard Hughes. It was certainly informational; everything I had previously known about Hughes came from a Simpsons episode (Mr. Burns dithering about the “Spruce Moose” - funny shit). But for fully-realized stories, biopics are by nature unwieldy; it’s better to focus on an interesting story than an interesting person.

Personal Aside To Oliver Stone: Mr. Stone, you have blamed the failure of Alexander on a number of things: unfair press, disgruntled Greek lawyers, homophobia, and a handful of other conspiracy theories. You failed to mention the following more probable reasons: your ego, production mismanagement, your ego, horrific casting, your ego, your love affair with Fidel Castro, and your ego. You have threatened to move to France because of your disappointment in American audiences. I’ll donate my frequent flyer miles if it will get you there any faster. I’m not saying I want you gone permanently; just don’t come back until you make great films, like you used to.

BEST ACTOR:
SHOULD WIN: Jamie Foxx (Ray)
WILL WIN: Jamie Foxx (Ray)
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Kevin Spacey (Beyond The Sea)
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Jim Carrey (Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind); Paul Giamatti (Sideways)

In the surprise of the year, Clint Eastwood got a nomination, while Paul Giamatti did not. How on earth could that happen? I'll tell you: a flawed nomination process and politics. Without going into too much detail (too late), nominations are determined solely on 1st place votes (2nd and 3rd place votes are only used if not enough people get 1st place votes). You can bet that Giamatti was a 2nd place vote on most of the ballots, but not 1st on any. Meanwhile, Clint (an Academy member with plenty of seniority, reverence, and voting friends) got some cronies to give him 1st place votes. It is very possible that Clint got a nomination with a handful of #1s (but zero #2s or #3s), while Giamatti got snubbed with all the #2s (but zero #1s). The process is designed to nominate 5 actors who could possibly win, rather than include everybody’s 2nd and 3rd favorite actors.

Personally, I think the nominees should be the Top 5 Actors Of The Year. In order to achieve that, a weighted voting process would be required (like the Heisman, NCAA polls, and baseball awards). Using such a procedure, Giamatti would have beaten Clint by a landslide. The current nomination process would be the equivalent of counting only #1 votes for the NCAA Football Coaches' Poll: Oklahoma and Nebraska would ALWAYS be ranked in the top 5, because their coaches ALWAYS get at least one #1 vote (by voting for themselves).

Giamatti is becoming a familiar name on my Snubbed list, after being passed over last year for American Splendor. But he might get his chance next year in a supporting role, as he’s already being touted as a “scene-stealer” in the Russell Crowe vehicle Cinderella Man. And if Jim Carrey had a nickel for every time he got screwed out of a nomination… well, he’d have about 15 cents. But for my money, this was his most deserving role to date. Forget the usual marveling about “such a departure” from his usual wacky on-screen antics; his somber heartbreak in Eternal Sunshine was one for the ages.

I am thrilled that Don Cheadle got a nomination, even if it was at the expense of Paul Giamatti. It’s amazing that America is just now starting to recognize his immense talent. I think Kevin Spacey is equally talented; I genuinely like him in almost every movie… but not in Beyond The Sea.

As for Golden Globe winner Leonardo DiCaprio... I’ll be blunt: I don’t think he’s a very good actor. I'm sure that doesn't bother him, and I assume he doesn't think much of me as a film critic. To his credit, I really enjoyed his scenes in The Aviator where he was disfigured and hospitalized; the only disappointment was that it was merely makeup. Honestly, there were a few scenes where I thought he was actually quite good, but I’ll have more on that in the Best Supporting Actress section. Suffice it to say, I won’t be thrilled if he wins the Oscar.

But this is all neither here nor there, because Jamie Foxx will win the Oscar in a landslide. He could have scored a nomination for Ray based on the previews alone. The bigger question is whether he’ll thank me in his acceptance speech. I really didn’t expect to be recognized in his Golden Globe speech. Although he didn’t mention me by name, I think it was obvious who he was referring to in the story about being “two drinks away from getting crazy in Miami over New Year’s”. Frankly, it’s a little embarrassing for me. After bumping into him last fall in Toronto, and twice in Miami, I fear he’s becoming my Kato Kaelin. Jamie, please, let go of my coattails.

BEST ACTRESS:
SHOULD WIN: Imelda Staunton (Vera Drake)
WILL WIN: Annette Bening (Being Julia)
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Nicole Kidman (Birth)
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Elisha Cuthbert (The Girl Next Door)

Here is a category that the Academy got right. No sub-par performances were included, and no outstanding performances were overlooked. I feared that Catalina Sandino Moreno would get left out for Maria Full Of Grace (small, foreign-language films tend not to get noticed in the big categories). As for the “Ingloriously Snubbed”: You think I’m kidding, which I am… mostly. Since I couldn’t just leave it blank, I could have gone with more obvious choices like Julie Delpy (Before Sunset) or Natalie Portman (Garden State). But nobody, and I mean nobody, lit up the screen this year like Elisha Cuthbert did in The Girl Next Door. I realize that being hot isn’t acting per se, but I think some credit is due for keeping so many (leering) eyes glued to the screen. Honestly, the only think keeping her from my “Should Win” prize was her lack of actual nudity in the film.

The race will come down to Annette Bening (Being Julia) and Imelda Staunton (Vera Drake). Instead of old versus young like last year, we have old versus older. Instead of ageism, we have patriotism. Instead of past beauty versus present beauty, we have past beauty versus always-was-ugly. Staunton is the most deserving, but she’s too unknown, too British, and in too small a film to win. Even with nominations for Director and Screenplay, you’d be hard pressed to find a voter that saw Vera Drake.

Many are calling this year’s title bout a re-match of the Bening / Swank fight in 2000, when Swank’s Boys Don’t Cry bested Bening’s American Beauty. Swank gave an amazing performance in Million Dollar Biznotch, but she won’t get the prize because she recently won, and she actually DID grow up in a trailer park (so her acting wasn’t much of a stretch). It’s true that Oscar loves the ingenue, but Swank no longer fits that description.

I think aging looker Bening will win, because her performance will resonate most with voters. Remember, the female voters are predominantly aging lookers themselves, and they’re friends of Bening’s (specifically, they are former conquests of Bening’s hubby and Thalberg winner Warren Beatty).

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR:
SHOULD WIN: Clive Owen (Closer)
WILL WIN: Morgan Freeman (Million Dollar Baby)
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: David Carradine (Kill Bill Vol. 2)
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Durmot Mulroney (Undertow); Mark Wahlberg (I <HEART> Huckabees)

Oh how things have come full circle. In 1993, if you asked me who the bigger star was, Thomas Hayden Church or George Clooney, I would have undoubtedly said Church. Clooney was an unrecognizable bit player from post-shark-jump series The Facts Of Life and Rosanne, while Church was the reason to tune into the hit Wings. Church was also the first one to leave Wings for bigger parts and bigger money - ahem, hence Ned And Stacy. But it was his own show, which Clooney has never had. If you ask me the same question today, I would still say Church, and here's why: Church has more career Oscar nominations (1 to 0), and Church beat out Clooney for the role in Sideways (honest to god). Please don't ask me the same question again next year, when Church is back to doing Icehouse radio ads.

While Church has never given such a quality performance (nor will he ever again), and has won most of the critics’ awards, it appears that Sideways is losing steam as the Oscars approach. The guy I’m rooting for, and the guy the Academy is rooting for, is Morgan Freeman. Everyone agrees that this is a man who, at some point in his life, deserves to own an Oscar. And in this year’s somewhat weak category, that point is nigh. Was Million Dollar Baby his best performance ever? Well, it’s pretty hard to top The Shawshank Redemption. But in this year’s tight race, it will be good enough.

Here’s some pretentious critic doublespeak for you: I’m rooting for Freeman, but I’m voting for Clive Owen. In Closer, Owen out-smarmed Church, and, I’m afraid, out-performed Freeman. It has taken longer than I thought for the James Bond heir-apparent to get invited to the A-List. This nomination gives him a serious boost, but he’s not quite there yet. An Oscar victory would solidify it, but I don’t think it’s going to happen. But I have a feeling that toting a license to kill will probably do the trick.

How does Jamie Foxx fit into all this? Whether or not he gave the best performance in Collateral (and yes, we all know it was a lead performance, not a supporting performance – tell that to Tom Cruise’s agent) is irrelevant. Since Foxx will unanimously win the Best Actor category, voters will simply not vote for the same person twice in the same year. It’s never happened, and it never will. The only way Foxx will win this statuette is if host Chris Rock steals it and gives it to him (which he has vowed to do if Foxx doesn’t win for Best Actor).

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS:
SHOULD WIN: Natalie Portman (Closer)
WILL WIN: Virginia Madsen (Sideways)
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Meryl Streep (The Manchurian Candidate)
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Kate Beckinsale (The Aviator) – based solely on her hotness

I never thought the circumstances would arise for me to say this, but: I agree with Angela Lansbury. The Manchurian Candidate should NOT have been re-made (I also happen to agree that Cabot Cove is a dangerous yet lovely place to live). And I don’t care if you ARE Meryl Streep, there is simply no topping Lansbury’s performance in the 1962 original.

As for Kate Beckinsale in The Aviator as “Ingloriously Snubbed”… okay, this time, I am kidding. But I wanted to somehow recognize the second-hottest woman on the planet (without recognizing Van Helsing). I mean, have you seen the Diet Coke ad? If not, www.dietcoke.com. A cop-out, you say? My real answer, you ask? Well… how about Sharon Warren from Ray? Is that better? Goddam film snobs.

Cate Blanchett, the Screen Actors Guild winner, is probably the best actress in this category, if you’re judging on pedigree, career resume, and pure talent (although Natalie Portman gives her a run for her money). However, I cannot see giving Blanchett the award for The Aviator. In fact, really only one scene blew it for me, but it was the most critical one: When we initially met her as Katharine Hepburn, her impersonation was more ridiculous than Martin Short’s. But once we settled into her character, and it became less of a caricature, it was a really nice performance. I don’t know much about acting (other than telling people they suck), but one thing struck me about Blanchett’s scenes: I didn’t think she was particularly terrific, but Leonardo DiCaprio, as annoying as he is, was outstanding in them. I can’t really say if the credit goes to acting, directing, or writing; but in any case, it was clear that her presence made the film and her co-stars better. But, I’m afraid, not good enough to win the Oscar.

While I thought Virginia Madsen was remarkable in Sideways, I have to give my vote to Portman. She gave the best performance, and I think I even gained some respect for her for choosing to exorcise the nude scenes from Closer. No, that’s not true. Regardless, she gave the best performance. I have been extremely impressed by her acting throughout her career (she was unbelievable in The Professional), but I was fairly disappointed by her recent admission that she phoned in her Star Wars performances because she didn’t feel motivated by the scripts. But she made up for it (somewhat) by her priceless line in Garden State: “I cannot believe you’re not retarded.”

BEST DIRECTOR:
SHOULD WIN: Clint Eastwood (Million Dollar Baby)
WILL WIN: Clint Eastwood (Million Dollar Baby)
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Marc Forster (Finding Neverland)
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Michel Gondry (Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind)

First and foremost, the rightful winner: Michel Gondry. He was hands-down this year’s best director. And I’m talking old-fashioned directing, not overseeing multi-million dollar CGI labs. 100% of his effects were camera tricks, manipulated perspective, or visual (not digital) effects. Need a room to disappear? He turned out the lights. Need a fuzzy background? He broke out the plastic wrap. Need Jim Carrey in two different places? He had Carrey run behind the camera and change clothes as the camera panned back and forth. This was inventive filmmaking, not “I want 200 orcs. No, make it 400 orcs. No, make it 10,000 orcs.” This year’s Director nominees are heralded because of the performances they drew out of their actors (Sideways, Ray, Million Dollar Baby, Vera Drake), but Gondry did that too (he scored Kate Winslet an acting nod, coached Carrey’s best-ever performance, and got Kirsten Dunst to flash the side of her boob), on top of the dazzling effects and mind-torquing storytelling.

So then what about the actual nominees? Everybody's saying, “I want Marty to win, but do I want him to win for THIS movie?” If it sounds familiar, it was the same thing they were saying about Scorsese in '03 for Gangs Of New York - and he lost. Scorsese has for some reason made Leonardo DiCaprio his De Niro of the 00s, and I don’t think that’s necessarily the horse he wants to hitch his wagon to. This year’s requisite hipster nomination goes to Alexander Payne for Sideways. Which means, of course, that he won’t win.

Unless an overwhelming sentimental vote goes to Scorsese, Clint Eastwood should win this one easily. He may well get sentimental votes himself: Anyone suffering from hobbit overload last year felt Eastwood should have won for steering Mystic River.

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY:
SHOULD WIN: Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
WILL WIN: Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: I <HEART> Huckabees; Maria Full Of Grace

Here’s an easy rule of thumb: Anytime Charlie Kaufman is nominated, he ought to win. And just as true: Anytime Charlie Kaufman is nominated, some other less-deserving script actually wins. But that could change this year. Had Eternal Sunshine gotten Director and Actor nominations, I would call it a slam dunk. But the dearth of nominations prove that voters are still too thick and too lazy to appreciate Kaufman’s scripts. But the fact is, there is no threatening competition this year (unless The Aviator goes on some kind of unlikely mad sweep), so expect a long-overdue victory for Charlie. Hopefully he’ll share it with Donald.

I can see that my choice for “Gloriously Omitted” raised a few eyebrows. People will probably assume I’m bashing Wes Anderson’s screenplay for The Life Aquatic, but I’m not - I really liked it. But let’s face it: It wasn’t his best script. It’s the only one he hasn’t written with Owen Wilson, and I’m afraid it shows. I have high expectations for Anderson, so I expect him to do better. He’s the honor student who disappoints me when he gets a B+. “But Wes, you have so much potential…”

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY:
SHOULD WIN: Sideways
WILL WIN: Sideways
GLORIOUSLY OMITTED: Bridget Jones: The Edge Of Reason
INGLORIOUSLY SNUBBED: Mean Girls

Ah, yes, the “Consolation Prize” category. In a tight Best Picture race, the loser often picks up the Adapted Screenplay award. And sure enough, if Million Dollar Baby wins Best Picture, expect Sideways to take Screenplay as a parting gift. And if Sideways wins Best Picture, MDB has a real chance at this award. But with its Golden Globe victory and months of strong buzz on the script, I think Sideways will take this award regardless of other race results. With all its above-the-line strengths, the screenplay is probably Million Dollar Baby’s weakest aspect.

What’s that? Yes, I saw Mean Girls, and yes, I liked it. Go ahead and laugh. Get it out of your system. Finished? In the hands of a lesser writer, I would have immediately dismissed the movie as recycled WB girlie teen garbage. But not in the hands of Tina Fey. There were tons of great lines, but “That is the ugliest f-ing skirt I have ever seen” still cracks me up.

What other award categories can I ruminate on…?

Best Animated Feature: I’ll go ahead and pick this category, because it’s a sure thing: The Incredibles. I am not above padding my stats.

Best Documentary Feature: While Super Size Me may seem like a fluff piece that doesn't deserve the prize, think about it this way: Activist documentarians aim to change the world with their films, but rarely achieve that. Morgan Spurlock, however, did. Although they deny it, McDonald's dropped the Super Size option because of the film. Compare that to the goal of Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11 (which violated Documentary rules because Moore showed the film on television, gambling on a Best Picture nomination). Moore tried to oust the President, and failed. Spurlock, despite the redneck-juvenile-prankishness of the film, succeeded where Moore failed. And I would argue that Spurlock had a bigger challenge: America holds Ronald McDonald in higher regard than it does the President. For me, Super Size Me deserves the Oscar on one scene alone, that wasn't even in the film (but was included in the DVD Special Features): Showing what happens (or doesn't happen) to McDonald’s fries after decaying for several months.

Best Soundtrack: Okay, this isn’t really an award. But it should be, right Fuse Nation? Runners-up would include Napoleon Dynamite (unironically incorporating The White Stripes AND Alphaville), Garden State (for mopey music snobs), and The Life Aquatic (for the acoustic David Bowie covers… in Portuguese). The award would go to The Girl Next Door. There really isn’t any original music to speak of in the film, but it’s like a mix tape (or should I get with the millennium and say “iTunes playlist”) of eclectic songs that sound really cool in each scene. It wins even after I deduct points for over-using the most over-used classic rock song ever, the Who’s “Baba O’Riley”. Napoleon Dynamite gets bonus points for the year’s best end-credit song: “The Promise” by 80s power-wimps When In Rome. Runner-up for end-credit song is Jersey Girl, boasting Pete Townshend’s “Let My Love Open The Door” re-mix.



Review This Item

Rating:

Comment:




Reviews


Submitted by dudaculb at 2005-03-05 13:50:10 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Excellent post, i think sideways was great too.

Submitted by Naery at 2005-03-02 00:02:19 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Tons of thought went into this. I'm impressed. I'm also a follower and bandwagon hopper, so I'll agree with everything you said.

Submitted by someone at 2005-03-01 23:45:53 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I love this type of shit. I agree 100 percent about Eternal Sunshine, although I haven't seen Sideways yet.

Submitted by RyuFu at 2005-02-28 14:33:11 EST (#)
Rating: 1

I'd do Hilary Swank. Trailer trash or not. I'd take her and Britney on. Then I'd wake up.

Submitted by tlozoot at 2005-02-27 23:56:15 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Ouch. Not very good this year eh?

I did pretty well, I'm pretty furious about Cate Blanchett this year. I really can't stand her, and she was especially bad in the Aviator. And she was my only incorrect pick.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-27 23:52:25 EST (#)
Rating: -1

I went 5-1...only missed Best Picture, dammit

Submitted by Degreeless_Capibara at 2005-02-27 23:33:42 EST (#)
Rating: -2

B@W

Submitted by DonovanMD at 2005-02-27 23:19:54 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Anyone named Donovan is ok in my book.

Submitted by bob at 2005-02-27 23:07:42 EST (#)
Rating: 2

CATALINA SHOULD HAVE WON...OR KATE WINSLET.

BUT NOT HILLARY SWANK

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Submitted by bob at 2005-02-27 23:07:01 EST (#)
Rating: 2

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HILLARY SHOULD HAVE LOST.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Submitted by antluvdog at 2005-02-27 12:51:16 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Eternal Sunshine was fucked over by the Oscars, destroying any credibility for the organization in my mind.

Submitted by Gent at 2005-02-25 22:02:02 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Great Again. Although I really like Carradine in "Kill Bill V:2"... not that he should've been nominated.

Submitted by Judoka at 2005-02-24 21:13:08 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I have been looking forward to your analisys for a while. You didnt dissapoint; thank you.

Submitted by SullyThePirate at 2005-02-23 11:49:39 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Submitted by T-Rock at 2005-02-22 11:00:18 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Excellent picks! But I gotta say, The Life Aquatic is the king of soundtracks, this year. Wes Anderson is a genius. Not only are the portugese Bowie covers done by Seu Jorge grand, the Mark Mothersbaugh tracks are, as usual, excellent! Some of his best work ever, including Devo and Mutato Muzika.

As for the Garden State soundtrack, well..it's good, but I think it's way overrated. But then again, I work at a music store, and get asked like...8 questions about it a day. So maybe I'm just bitter.

Submitted by Beer_bong at 2005-02-17 01:15:30 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Submitted by bob (user info) at 2005-02-15 22:23:31 (#)
Ranking: 2

Hotel Rwanda needs to win something. That was such a great movie.

Submitted by Rawrg at 2005-02-17 00:15:25 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I enjoyed this much, thank you.

Submitted by ASO at 2005-02-16 23:47:32 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Blade Trinity should have won all categories.

Submitted by Ingsoc at 2005-02-16 23:35:56 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Sideways is just about the only film on here that I've seen.

Submitted by chicagogirl at 2005-02-16 20:46:55 EST (#)
Rating: 2

the fight scene on the golf course in sideways was hilarious.

Submitted by c1ndy at 2005-02-16 12:07:13 EST (#)
Rating: 2

we get films later in the UK so i haven't seen everything you write about yet, but I just saw sideways this week and thought it was great, I loved eternal sunshine, and collateral (good point about the lead thing) i haven't seen ray but i bet it wins stuff.

Submitted by peckerhead at 2005-02-16 11:46:37 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I don't understand what happened to my post below: There are words missing. No, not typo's. Words MISSING. for example: "will only survive as movies where the members are the winners" was actually typed as: "... will only survive as movies where the members are the winners..."

Farther down, I made reference to "... young s..." Maybe even more words are missing; Sorry but it's not my fault. In any case the general gist was and is okay. Strange!?

Submitted by peckerhead at 2005-02-16 11:35:54 EST (#)
Rating: 2

First of all: Excellent job; thanks for the time and effort you obviously put into this. Thanks for the tips re "Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind" starring Jim Carrey. Maybe Jim Carrey is one of those guys who will not be understood in his own time; maybe his better efforts - including "the Truman Show" will only survive as movies where the members are the winners whereas typical movie goers kid themselves that they are seeing great movies, when in fact, the biggest box office hits are rarely the best fare. I digress.
Ryan, I am in conflict over Million Dollar Baby. I saw it a few days ago and personally, I think it is a masterpiece. I fully agree that Clint should win best Director. If he was 10 yrs younger, he may well have pulled off "best actor" too. My conflict is this: How do I recommend the movie and caution people at the same time. This movie took a lot out of me; I was one of those patrons sitting in my seat long after "the End", emotionally drained and thinking, "Wow." I just wonder how many young s and especially teenagers will be able to handle this movie(?) I am in awe of the writers and Producers for the enormous gamble they took. I think I better shut up now. If anyone has read this far then know that Million Dollar Baby is one amazing movie. See it, but not on an evening when you are seeking light entertainment or a simple feel good movie. Million Dollar Baby is much much more. In my humble opinion, it will likely become a classic. It may well become the standard by which other movies of this genre are measured against. Once again, Ryan, thank you and good luck with your predictions; I'll be back for move excellent movie reviews next year :-)

Submitted by firefly at 2005-02-16 10:30:19 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Submitted by Caulaincourt at 2005-02-16 10:03:13 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-16 09:57:15 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Don Cheadle is a great actor.

Will Smith is the Fresh Prince of Belair.

That should have pretty much made the decision for the producers of Hotel Rwanda right there.

Submitted by zakalwe at 2005-02-16 09:42:39 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Eternal Sunshine should get them all. Apart from that have only seen Collateral.

Submitted by Zoidberg at 2005-02-16 03:16:23 EST (#)
Rating: 0

Schlong, did you know Hollywood was trying to get them to use Will Smith in Hotel Rwanda?


Will "MIB" Smith. Yeah, thats good casting right there...

Submitted by bart at 2005-02-16 02:11:10 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Ray Charles will get the dead man sweep with the Grammy's and Best Actor award. I'm waiting for him and Tupac to release an album together in early 2006.


I'm disappointed that you didn't put Lindsey Lohan in one of your snubbed mentions.

Submitted by JMG114 at 2005-02-16 01:07:44 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Copycat!

Not really. Always good to read your stuff.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 23:04:23 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Here's one mention of it.

Without Don Cheadle, no one would have went to see Hotel Rwanda.

How's that?

Submitted by Zoidberg at 2005-02-15 22:59:02 EST (#)
Rating: 0

not one mention of Hotel Rwanda?

Submitted by Adjomak at 2005-02-15 22:56:45 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Eh, don't listen to em. Bang up job.

Submitted by Spooner at 2005-02-15 22:55:33 EST (#)
Rating: 2

"Spooner: In response to your review of my Fun With Real E-mail, Part 6."



Ah, ok. I'm filled with guarded optimism.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:49:44 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Don't be surprised, Mr. Wizard. I just admitted it, you stupid fuck.

Funny is funny, no matter who types it or speaks it.

Submitted by Tom Sorrell at 2005-02-15 22:48:23 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Why am I not surprised that you laugh at your own jokes?

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:45:08 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Don't feel bad, Tommyboy...I laughed at it while I typed it.

Submitted by Tom Sorrell at 2005-02-15 22:42:14 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Submitted by Shlongy (user info) at 2005-02-15 22:31:02 (#)
Ranking: -1

Don't upset him...He's apparently under some kind of misconception that if he gives you a "tribute post", it's very special.

Just thank him...and back away very slowly...make no sudden moves.

---

Ok, I hate to admit it, but I actually laughed at that.

Spooner: In response to your review of my Fun With Real E-mail, Part 6.

Submitted by Can_Always_Trust_A_Liar at 2005-02-15 22:41:58 EST (#)
Rating: 2

"The Macho Man to Bart's Hogan."

+2 for the best analogy I've ever heard in my life.

Submitted by Wiggles at 2005-02-15 22:41:13 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Truthfully, I thought Sideways was nothing more than a fairly simple little buddy comedy, but I suppose it was better than anything else. Maybe not Ray.

Submitted by Can_Always_Trust_A_Liar at 2005-02-15 22:40:30 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I loved Eternal Sunshine, I'm disapointed in the lack of nominations.


I also happen to agree on The Life Aquatic. good, but I prefered the Royal Tenenbaums.

Submitted by wardy at 2005-02-15 22:38:20 EST (#)
Rating: 2

+2 because you've seen a shit load of movies i've never heard of...

Submitted by Kazzerax at 2005-02-15 22:35:26 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Sweet. What's your AIM? My AIM-ZakTheFlame

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:34:48 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Hey Donovan...do you take requests?




I'd like to hear "Atlantis" please.

Submitted by intellismartness at 2005-02-15 22:32:02 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Eternal Sunshine was a great movie, and this post was exceptional.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:31:02 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Don't upset him...He's apparently under some kind of misconception that if he gives you a "tribute post", it's very special.

Just thank him...and back away very slowly...make no sudden moves.

Submitted by gob_bluth at 2005-02-15 22:30:03 EST (#)
Rating: 0

No BloodSport - no pos 2

http://www.ubersite.com/m/59724


Submitted by Spooner at 2005-02-15 22:29:37 EST (#)
Rating: 2

What the fuck? Tribute post? When'd you promise a tribute post?

Submitted by dodahdave at 2005-02-15 22:25:24 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Whoa, here I am and here's a Donovan post.

Nice picks.

Submitted by Tom Sorrell at 2005-02-15 22:24:41 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I'm the same way with you, Spoon Man. Expect the tribute post I promised within the week.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:24:05 EST (#)
Rating: -1

BTG has more estrogen in his system than 31.8% of all broads.

Submitted by bob at 2005-02-15 22:23:31 EST (#)
Rating: 2

Hotel Rwanda needs to win something. That was such a great movie.

Submitted by Spooner at 2005-02-15 22:22:00 EST (#)
Rating: 2

BTG is getting defensive. Awwwwww, it's kinda cute...

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:19:58 EST (#)
Rating: -1

Yeah...I see now that this is his "shtick".

Fortunately for me, I still don't care.

I upped it for his #9 ID badge.

Submitted by Tom Sorrell at 2005-02-15 22:18:23 EST (#)
Rating: 2

He does this every year, you fucking douchebags. Shut your holes and let the man do his thing. His last post was Oc-damn-tober, for God's sake.

This guy is the Batman to Bart's Superman.

The Macho Man to Bart's Hogan.

The Edge to Bart's Bono.

The Steve Young to Bart's Joe Montana.

PLUS FUCKING TWO

Submitted by GodLovesALittleLovin at 2005-02-15 22:17:12 EST (#)
Rating: 2

aw, snap! I'm sure to win that e-mail from bart now!!!

...god i'm such a loser.

Submitted by AJ at 2005-02-15 22:17:02 EST (#)
Rating: 2

B@W

Submitted by Spooner at 2005-02-15 22:16:06 EST (#)
Rating: 2

I liked Kill Bill Vol. 2. =(

Submitted by Tom Sorrell at 2005-02-15 22:15:01 EST (#)
Rating: 2

WOOOO! Ryan Donovan is in the hizzy!!!!!

+2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2
+2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2
+2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2
+2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2
+2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2 +2

You are the reason I came to Uber, and now I am right behind you on the MVA. Thank you for your writings.

Submitted by Shlongy at 2005-02-15 22:14:51 EST (#)
Rating: -2

Couldn't you just vote in the Uberpoll like everyone fucking else?

Submitted by MyNameIsTim at 2005-02-15 22:14:44 EST (#)
Rating: 1

wow.

i dont' care.

but you have an ID # of 9.

that's impressive.


Laser effects, mirrored balls -- John Williams must be rolling around
in his grave.

-- Homer Simpson
The Springfield Connection